NOVANEWSHelen Thomas, hypocrisy here and thereIt’s impossible to defend Grande Dame of White House journalists Helen Thomas’recent off the cuff statement that Israeli Jews should go back to Germany…..or Poland. (She said Israel should get out of Palestine, but it wasn’t clear if shemeant the Occupied Territories, which Israelis should get out of, or Israel behindthe green line.) It was deeply offensive and wrong.One of this country’s most important and courageous journalists said somethingterribly wrong, was massively criticized, apologized for it, and was forced intoretirement. Exactly the way it should be, right? Wrong.It’s hard to even chart out the hypocrisy of the whole affair. What happened in 2002when House Republican Majority Leader Dick Armeycalled for the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians on MSNBC’s Hardball? An outragedresponse? Nary a peep. That same year Senator James Inhofe also called for Israelto permanently retain all of the Occupied Territories, “Because God said so. “Did he quit? No. And what to make of the fact that Obama’s White Housesummoned infinitely more moral outrage for Thomas’ terrible but certainlynot lethal remarks, than for the death of 9 people on the Mavi Marmara, includinga 19-year-old US citizen shot in the head. (One prompted “deep regret”, the otherwas “reprehensible”. Guess which was which.)There’s also the glass house in which Rabbi Nessenoff lives: he’s the one who recordedthe Thomas gotcha video and who, it seems, has offered the world his ownoffensive imitation of a Mexican priest, and believes that Palestinians all belong back home…in Jordan.Taking a short trip over to Israel we discover that the Israeli military recently createdan order that, according to many human rights groups and Ha’aretz,“will enable mass deportation from West Bank.” Who had to retire because of that?Maybe because it wasn’t an off the cuff remark to suggest ethnic cleansing, but anactual military order to allow it, its authors escaped opprobrium. Wacky!Just this week, Likud party MK, Miri Regev shouted at Hanin Zuabi, an Arab memberof the Knesset from Nazareth who went on the Gaza flotilla,“Get back to Gaza, you traitor!” Sounds familiar, as though Thomas herself couldhave said it. Outrage meter? Zero. Then again, Israeli Interior Minister Eli Yishaiwants Zuabi stripped of her Israeli citizenship, so telling her to go back to a placeshe is not from actually seems pretty mild by those standards.Moshe Yaroni, who abhors what Thomas said,compares her treatment to Israel’s response to the Jerusalem Post’s Caroline Glickwho is surely responsible for what will go down as one of the most morally heinouspieces of agitprop in modern history:
The punch line, of course, is that because of her truly abominable and utterly vilevideo, Caroline Glick and is being hailed as a Hasbara hero in Israel- while one ofour few truly great journalists has ended an otherwise remarkable career. Yaronicontinues:
Grit Tv’s Laura Flanders may be onto something when she says:
I’m not sure. Had Helen Thomas made a similar remark about African Americans,for example, it’s possible the same fate would have befallen her. If only I could feelconfident that all those power-brokers cared as much about my Arab and Muslimfriends as they seem to care about me… as a Jew of course.
|
|