NOVANEWS
-
Don’t lose heart. This struggle is a long one
-
Impounded US boat to Gaza
-
A despairing conversation with an Arab friend at the Four Seasons
-
This is the Freedom Ride of our era
-
Shorter Israeli consul-general: ‘I don’t know any details and have a great day’
-
‘LA Times’ fails to state that ‘law prof’ writing that Gaza siege is legit is ex-IDF Lawyer
-
Alice Walker on the ‘many impediments orchestrated by the Israeli gov’t’
-
Despite many setbacks, US boat did damage to Israel’s public image
-
70 cyclists committed to ‘bikes without borders’ are prevented from going into Hebron’s Old City
Don’t lose heart. This struggle is a long one
Jul 02, 2011
Ahmed Moor
Evidently, the Israelis and Americans (and the French and Germans?) have succeeded in pressuring the failing Greek government into preventing the flotilla from sailing. As Medea Benjamin pointed out earlier, this likely has a lot to do with Greece’s sovereign debt crisis.
While many of us feel angry, it’s probably best not to direct our anger at the Greek government. After all, here is a coalition which has surrendered its sovereign decision-making process in order to secure a few more billion stopgap dollars. And for all its troubles – for the hot humiliation of being dictated to – the Papandreou government will likely still be “restructured.” The average Greek deserves our sympathy for the years of economic and social pain they’re in for (probably, the average EU citizen too).
Collectively, it’s important for activists to remember that the flotilla isn’t a goal unto itself. The main objective here is to draw attention to numerous Israeli violations of international law (chiefly, ghettoizing a people through collective punishment for racial difference). The dedicated activists on the Gaza-bound ships are risking their lives to publicize the human rights and needs of the Palestinians in Gaza. That’s where the focus ought to remain.
The main project at hand is working towards a just solution to the conflict, which I believe means overcoming Zionism. All indications suggest that we’re succeeding at an astonishing pace (remember, W&M and Carter’s book were published only five years ago).
The recent Michelle Goldberg review of Lisa Baron’s book is representative of the kind of progress that we’re making. Goldberg (and the post here which highlighted the review) both noted that Baron feels compelled to fellate the Republican Party because she’s a Zionist.
What’s more interesting, however, is that Goldberg (I’m guessing that she’s Jewish, but I may be wrong) locates Zionism as a distant phenomenon, something away from her.
She writes about the “the perversity of the Zionist alliance between hawkish Jews and the Christian right.” Her words and framing suggest that she herself is set apart from Zionism – that it’s something deviant Republicans are into.
I may be taking too much from words that are particularized and non-generalizable; I don’t know Goldberg personally. But she is a writer for the liberal(ish) Daily Beast who locates Zionism distally. More importantly, she doesn’t make any obvious attempt to reclaim Zionism for the left. I believe the trend will continue; Zionism is the hole where Shelly Adelson hunkers down with Rudy Giuliani to scare small children.
But back to the flotilla: It is far from a foregone conclusion that the flotilla has been successfully undermined by Obama and Netanyahu. I’m hopeful that it will still sail.
We must recognize however, that the flotilla may not sail.
It is easy to feel powerless, helpless and small when faced with the combined power of large states and supranational institutions, particularly when they’re subordinated to nefarious personal ambitions and special interests. But this is not the time lose heart.
The Palestinian struggle is a long one. The Palestinian people have experienced heartbreak after setback after shocking disappointment for generations now.
And yet, the struggle continues. Indeed, Palestinian resilience is a hallmark of the struggle. Our struggle will continue for the foreseeable future; this won’t get any easier.
In the nearer term, the Papandreou government will fail. The special-interest automatons occupying the dining rooms of the Four Seasons on both sides of the Atlantic will fail. That’s partly because activists will double, redouble, and treble their efforts. But it’s also because the Obamas of the world are hollow and cynical: shiny trinkets do not comprise a value system.
We are driven by the unyielding belief in justice, above all. We are unmovable. And we will prevail.
Impounded US boat to Gaza
Jul 02, 2011
Philip Weiss
The US Boat to Gaza published the picture above of its impounded vessel today.
I’m in a desperate mood today. Two tweets sum it up:
From Saree Makdisi: So: armed struggle is out; international law is out; ICJ is out;UN is out; aid flotillas are out; negotiations are out; what is left?
From JVP:
pers @ NY Greek Consulate told JVP supporter “It’s your government [US] that ordered us not to let the ship sail!” link to twitter.com
A despairing conversation with an Arab friend at the Four Seasons
Jul 02, 2011
Philip Weiss
Two days ago in New York’s Four Seasons hotel, I met a sophisticated friend from the Arabian peninsula whose identity I must disguise, and we had a grim conversation. He made a number of points:
–The situation in Israel/Palestine is very bleak. There is no way out. The Israelis have the power, and they will continue to make life intolerable for Palestinians in the occupied territories, until those who can leave, leave. And of course the educated Israelis are also all leaving…
–The U.S. still has the power over Palestine’s future, as it did in 1948. Empires are built slowly and they collapse slowly. The U.S. is the hegemon for the foreseeable future. And when it comes to Israel, there is no countervailing force to American support for Israel. Europe is nothing. The Arab world is nothing. The nations of the General Assembly are nothing. The non-Zionist movement inside the U.S.– come on, it is very small.
–We (Arabs) always told the U.S. that we can’t abandon Palestine because it is an issue of our identity. This we have explained for 70 years. Palestine is part of our identity, it cannot be subjugated. We have also explained that if the Palestinians accept a two-state solution, we would accept it. Would we accept an Israeli Jerusalem? Of course not. We can’t; Jerusalem must be shared.
–You (Mondoweiss) are naive about power.
Morality means nothing without power. Yes, you talk about the civil rights movement, inside your country. But that was a domestic frame. In the international frame, there is only power. These countries talk about the International Criminal Court for Gadafyi and for Bashar al-Assad, but you will never see a prosecution of an Israeli or an American for war crimes. Because who has the power.
–For supporters like myself of Arab liberation, freedom in Palestine was always a necessary but insufficient condition. Not until the subjugation of Palestine ends can the Arab world be liberated. The other condition is of course the end of the dictators. The Egyptian revolution is not a revolution yet. The regime has not been changed. And this is everything. Egypt is everything for the Arab world. If the Tunisian revolution succeeds, and Egypt fails, Tunisia does not matter.
–I admit that I did not foresee the Egyptian uprising. I have studied Arab politics forever and I was completely surprised. Maybe I will also be surprised by Palestine. But everything has failed for the Palestinians. Violent resistance failed. Negotiation failed. What do they have left? Yes I have always called for nonviolent resistance to create a democracy between the river and the sea, I was against Oslo. Because what do they get: Fayyad. They must elect a collaborationist government for their own occupation.
–You say the Israel lobby is a special interest. I disagree. I have lived in Washington. A special interest is not as integrated into the cultural and political life as this lobby is. Jews are an integral part of the American establishment. The media– the top layers are well over 50 percent Jewish. The political class? Finance? You have the complete integration of people who are indoctrinated in Zionism.
–Of course, you are not a Zionist. I can’t tell you how much I like what the Jewish non-Zionists and anti-Zionists are saying. But you are such a small group. I will tell you the ones I can’t stand. The liberal Zionists. I have more respect for the hard core Zionists, they tell you what they want. All the liberal Zionists do is whine and do nothing. Look at the New York Review of Books. But that man Daniel Levy interests me. I think that at his heart he is no longer a Zionist.
I (this is Weiss talking now) told my friend that Levy’s path (his brave statement at J Street earlier this year, “I’m not convinced that [the two-state solution] is the only model”) is one that many other American Jews are following. And we will be part of the countervailing force in American politics that will end the lobby. You can’t maintain a regime of anti-Arab racism in American life for 70 years (one that has been so costly to Americans, from the USS Liberty to the killing of Bobby Kennedy to Rachel Corrie to the Palestinian motivation for the 9/11 attack) without changing the channel. History moves. We are going to have another chapter. American realists are on our side, the military thinkers are on our side, Arab-Americans…
Of course when I got home, I saw the grim news from the flotilla and recognized that the US still runs the table here, and we are all prisoners of the Israel lobby. And as for my friend’s social understanding about the nature of the Establishment, well, I share it: Jews are empowered as never before, and Obama’s fears about the pro-Israel-Jewish presence in the Democratic Party make it impossible for him to be fair in this arena. And all this leaves me feeling only greater urgency about the need to end the fever of Zionism inside American Jewish life.
This is the Freedom Ride of our era
Jul 02, 2011
annie
I’m crying over this video. 193 hits, Let’s push it. It’s not over til the fat lady sings
Shorter Israeli consul-general: ‘I don’t know any details and have a great day’
Jul 02, 2011
Philip Weiss
From Democracy Now, an interview with the Israeli consul-general. I’ve cut out a lot of the talking points, and this is what you get:
AMY GOODMAN: Is Greece working with the Israeli government in stopping the flotilla from taking off?
IDO AHARONI: Look, I’m not familiar with the details of what is happening exactly between, as you know, I am positioned here in the United States, and I can tell you that we are very happy on the public position taken by a number of countries in Europe as well as the U.S. administration that contends that the very idea of flotilla is a provocation, unneeded one, illegitimate one.
JUAN GONZALEZ: Consul General, this issue, the statements that financial links have been uncovered between Hamas and the flotilla organizers, could you elaborate on that?
IDO AHARONI: Well, I don’t know enough details on that as well…
AMY GOODMAN: I wanted to ask you about the Israeli newspaper Maariv, which quoted several unnamed members of Israel’s security cabinet as saying the army’s claims were media spin and public relations hysteria, saying security cabinet ministers were given no such information when they were briefed on the flotilla this week. That is, information about arms, about chemical use that’s expected, anything like that.
IDO AHARONI: I don’t really know, what more do you need than the living proof of 45,000 rockets shelled on to innocent civilians, children, women, the elderly?…
JUAN GONZALEZ: Consul General, the organizers of the flotilla have raised these issues that several of their ships have been sabotaged, and they believe that Israel would be the only one who would be interested in doing that and they believe Israel is behind it. Can you say publicly that Israel has not been involved in any kind of sabotage attempts on these ships?
IDO AHARONI: Look, this is the most irrelevant question, whether the ships were sabotaged or not. The entire idea of the flotilla is unneeded, not necessary, and it is not legitimate. ..
AMY GOODMAN: So, Consul General, you are not denying responsibility for sabotaging these boats?
IDO AHARONI: Well, I don’t know the details. I have no idea what the organizers are claiming. I haven’t seen any of those claims, but I can tell you that the whole idea of the flotilla is unnecessary, and we have no interest in dealing with it, and hopefully the flotilla will not leave to be on its way to Israel.
AMY GOODMAN: Let me ask you another question and it’s about the journalists. The Israeli government has said that journalists who cover the flotilla will be banned from Israel for 10 years. Why?
IDO AHARONI: I think that this statement was reversed by the government, which issued another statement that journalists are welcome to board the ship we have nothing to hide.
AMY GOODMAN: So, will they not be arrested? We have our own journalists on board, our reporters are there in Athens and planning to board the ship. They will not be arrested? Do we have these guarantees, and their equipment, our cameras, will not be confiscated?
IDO AHARONI: Again, I don’t know the details. I guess that the people that will board the ship probably have to find information themselves. I can tell you that based on the statements of the Israeli government released, the Israeli press is more than welcome to cover the actions of the Israeli navy.
AMY GOODMAN: National press, not just Israeli press?
IDO AHARONI: You asked me about a statement that is part of the Israeli Press and a statement that was issued by the Israeli government. It’s part of the Israeli press and as the Prime Minister’s office clarified this decision was reversed and the media is more than welcome to, we’re operating in full transparency.
AMY GOODMAN: I wanted to follow up on a point you just made about what happened in November of 2008. An official Israeli government publication, theIsraeli Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center, reported, “Hamas was careful to maintain the cease-fire” and only fired rockets at Israel “in retaliation,” after Israel broke the cease-fire on November 4th. This is an Israeli government publication.
IDO AHARONI: Well, I want to tell you something. You don’t really have to do more than just look at the Hamas Charter, this is an organization that openly calls for the annihilation of the state of Israel….
AMY GOODMAN: But the people on board the ship are people like the 87-year-old Holocaust survivor, Hedy Epstein, the Pulitzer Prize-winning novelist Alice Walker, the well known labor lawyer Richard Levy, and others. These are the people who say that they are trying to challenge the blockade of Gaza, which brings me to this question, Consul General. Is Gaza occupied by Israel?
IDO AHARONI: The people that participate in this flotilla have to know what they’re doing and which organization they are endorsing and Hamas is a terrorist organization that totally negates the goals of the Palestinian national movement and our idea of a two state solution. …
AMY GOODMAN: But just that follow up on, is Israel occupying Gaza? Because it goes to the issue of whosw waters are off of the coast of Gaza? Does Israel have the right to intervene there?
IDO AHARONI: The reality on the ground is very simple, the facts are very simple. In August of 2005, the government of the state of Israel put an end to thousands of households in [inaudible] that practically handed over the keys to Gaza. Hamas, instead of turning it into an oasis, turned it into a safe haven for terrorists. It is something that no government, including the Israeli government, should accept. Thank you so much and have a great day.
AMY GOODMAN: Thank you very much for joining us. We have just been speaking with the Consul General of Israel in New York, Ido Aharoni.
‘LA Times’ fails to state that ‘law prof’ writing that Gaza siege is legit is ex-IDF Lawyer
Jul 02, 2011
Ira Glunts
Amos Guiora had an op-ed in the LA Times yesterday which seeks to justify the Israeli blockade of Gaza and its plans to stop the Freedom Flotilla. The arguments Professor Guiora employs are standard Israeli hasbara which makes you wonder why the paper chose to print this uninspired and hackneyed piece.
Guiora, who is an Israeli citizen, was born and educated in the US, is identified only as a law professor at the University of Utah and the author of Freedom from Religion: Rights and National Security. What the newspaper does not reveal is that Guiora spent 18 years in command positions in the Israeli Defense Forces, having risen to the rank of Lieutenant Colonel in the Judge Advocate General Corps. This omission has been brought to the attention of the editors, but there has not been any correction made.
I first learned about Guiora in 2007 when my wife and I were writing about a “lawfare” institute at Syracuse University. At that time, Guiora was the head of The Institute for Global Security Law and Policy at Case Western University which he had founded. The institute was a typical “lawfare” shop that advocated changing international humanitarian law relating to asymmetrical warfare. The idea was to avoid troublesome charges about the use of disproportionate force by armies against insurgencies. Naturally Guiora was a strong supporter of the 2006 Israeli invasion of Lebanon and defended the IDF against charges of crimes in the conduct of that war.
In a 2006 interview with the Cleveland Jewish News, Professor Guiora outrageously claimed that Israel is a proxy for the Western world in what he predicted would be a one hundred year war against the Arabs. This is just one of a number of highly controversial and idiosyncratic statements this “Strangelove” has made. Many are available on the Net.
H/T to Watcher who asks that you write to the LA Times, here, requesting that they inform their readers of Guiora’s IDF history. See his post for more on Guiora.
Alice Walker on the ‘many impediments orchestrated by the Israeli gov’t’
Jul 02, 2011
Philip Weiss
Alice Walker wrote a poem on the US Boat. It’s at this link, at Facebook, and includes these lines:
That a boat
filled
with love letters
from children
is a threat
to those
with
apparently
little memory
of youth
or experience
of love.
And it is introduced with this note:
Today is, I think, the 31st of June (Friday?) or is it the1st of July?
We have been in Athens since the 21st – trying to get to Gaza. Many impediments orchestrated by the Israeli government. But what a wonderful group of humans.
Therefore: We’ve won. We’re in Gaza. To be in Gaza is to feel this love. To know there is always a part of humanity that is awake even though the overburdened or the bewitched remain sleeping.
My throat is sore from breathing the tear gas that drifted into our hotel windows, as Greeks, mostly young, battle police, their brothers and sisters who are paid to keep them in line. This is the tragedy. I feel so much compassion for both sides my eyes tear and not only from the gas.
It was hard to breathe. My lungs were fighting hard to protect me. How I adore them, my lungs. And so many of our group tried to protect us, my lungs and me, too. A lovely young man named Steve gave me his own gas mask and someone else, a beautiful young woman with straw colored hair and blue gray eyes gave me the benefit of her knowledge of how to wear it.
I do not like calling such angels “blonde” as I feel the word is so loaded now and it sets them outside of Nature and somehow diminishes them.
I spent a blissful hour yesterday massaging Hedy’s feet. She has the most wonderful gray eyes – full of humor and light. She’d never had a foot massage before, she said. And she is eighty-seven! Hard to imagine.
Hedy, I said – when she told everyone who passed by us: “I’m being spoiled” – I have a full body massage at least once a week!
This was a high point for me, as it is well established by now in myself and among my friends, that I like to massage the feet of anyone who stands up for us. Humanity, I mean.
Or the other animals.
Hedy, holocaust survivor, inhaling the gas in Greece, but even more poignant, anticipating being tear gassed by the Israelis who are doing everything they can to threaten our boat.
I have no computer – they said not to bring one on the boat because it would likely by destroyed or confiscated – only this small notebook in which I have been avoiding writing the poem that starts and stops in my head: