Mondoweiss Online Newsletter

NOVANEWS

 

Posted BY: Sammi Ibrahem

Chair of Palestine Solidarity Campaign

 

Report: Israel used white phosphorus in latest Gaza attacks

Apr 19, 2011

Philip Weiss

From Ahram. Speechless-making. A doctor in the Gaza justice department’s medical office says that injuries to bodies in Gaza, charred, torn, indicate that white phosphorus was used by Israel in latest attacks. Where is international law?

U.S. Treasury says: There’s nothing to see on tax-exempt support for illegal settlements
Apr 18, 2011 11:44 pm | Alex Kane

Investigative journalist and author Grant Smith‘s “Israel Lobby Archive” project gets a response from a Freedom of Information Act request filed in 2007, which asked for access to internal Treasury Department records on programs to stop or investigate charitable funds going to illegal Israeli settlements. (Read the Institute for Research: Middle East Policy statement on the response here.)

The department responded, in so many words, that they don’t do anything about it, despite the very public nature of the problem:

Unfortunately, we were unable to locate or identify any responsive records pertaining to:

Internal reports about Treasury Department investigations triggered by public revelations that U.S. charitable funds flows used are used to illegally confiscate Palestinian lands and commit crimes overseas;

Meeting minutes of key Treasury Department 0fficials charged with combating money laundering conducted in Israel and the U.S. dealing with the Sasson report money laundering issues especially those with a focus on U.S. divisions of Hadassah, B’nai B’rith and other U.S. organizations managing WZO money laundering.

While the Treasury Department says it has “responsive information pertaining to Treasury Department programs designed to combat U.S. charitable money laundering to the West Bank,” the documents don’t say anything substantive on that topic. The documents attached to the request consist of already online presidential orders, like the prohibition on transactions with organizations designated by the U.S. as “terrorist” organizations.

But the Treasury Department is doing nothing about the (at least) hundreds of millions of tax-exempt dollars that flow to illegal settlements on occupied land. It is doing nothing about the New York-based Hebron Fund, which openly raises money for racist, extremist Israeli settlers who make the lives of Palestinians in Hebron hell. It is doing nothing aboutFriends of the Ateret Cohanim and Friends of Ir David, who are actively engaged in the colonization of Palestinian land in occupied Jerusalem.

Nothing to see here.

Alex Kane, a freelance journalist in New York, writes on Israel/Palestine and Islamophobia in the United States atalexbkane.wordpress.com, where this post originally appeared.  Follow him on Twitter @alexbkane.

Vittorio bore his burden to the land of pain

Apr 18, 2011

Mohammed Said AlNadi

drawingDrawing of Vittorio Arrigoni by his friend Shahd Abu Salama

Vittorio, your memory will live on forever

I, as every Palestinian is, am in shock at the human capacity for atrocity. Until this moment, I still can’t believe that Vik was murdered here, in Gaza, in the land he loved the most, the land he heartily embraced.

I didn’t know Vik very well, but now we all do in our hearts, thoughts and prayers. Since I’m friends with most of the International Solidarity Movement activists, I used to see Vik around. However, every time, I would be taken aback by his humbleness and sense of humor.

Everyone who knew Vik said he was nothing but a compassionate human rights defender, an individual who left everything behind—his first homeland Italy (I say “first” because Palestine was his second country), his family, his friends, his luxurious life and came to Gaza to support, help and give the people of Gaza. He came to Gaza because he was of a clear conscience and a pure soul. He refused to stand still and watch like so many others did. He could have helped from afar, but he insisted to come, to see firsthand all the crimes Israel was committing against the civilian population of Gaza. He tirelessly documented Israeli violations against human rights in Palestine, including the Gaza war. He accompanied every fisherman, risking his own life so many times; he wiped away the tears on the faces of every child; he always was there for the poor.

Vik passed and left his memories indelibly inscribed in our hearts. He taught us how to love, care, defend and sacrifice for the sake of others. He set the whole world an inspiring example of real heroism.

On Vik’s birthday, I didn’t go to his party, but some of our mutual trusted friends bought a cake and went to his apartment to celebrate it. Guess what they found him doing on his own birthday? My friends told me he was crying because his father’s health condition was critical. Isn’t that rare? Who of us would do a similar thing nowadays? I assume very few. When he was supposed to be there for his father taking care of him, though painful to him, he bore this burden to the land of pain, Gaza, where he chose to belong.

One’s death is compensated for by the legacy he or she leaves. It is the comfort which spurs other followers to hold the torch again and continue on the path towards freedom and justice. Vik left behind a treasure of human principles and values for everyone who wants to be a human. “Stay Human,” the title of his book, alone would fill the world peace and justice.

Yes we are sorry, and we know we are not going to see him again, but his heroic deeds and honorable achievements will never die. His eternal memories will remain a source of inspiration to all of us. And if they managed to eliminate his body, they will never be able to kill his ubiquitous soul, and many others will take the same route.

Vik, you did a great job…much reverence to your soul…

Turks mourn ‘Palestine’s son’

Apr 18, 2011

Philip Weiss

vittorio

Coverage of Vittorio Arrigoni’s funeral in theTurkish paper Hurriyet is extensive. Palestine’s Son is their headline. Thanks to Robert of Antalya.


Bronfman’s Passover questions come 10 years too late

Apr 18, 2011

Ilene Cohen

Here in Haaretz is Edgar Bronfman—philanthropist, international Jewish organizational leader, friend of Israel—offering a reconsideration of Passover that says it’s all right to criticize Israel: “Suporting Israel means questioning its policies.” Wading into such dangerous territory, he’s obviously glad to have David Grossman for cover, as Bronfman writes:

As we [Grossman and Bronfman] came to the end of our discussion we sat as two Jews – one from North America and one from Israel – who deeply care about our mutual fate as part of the Jewish people. He looked me in the eye and said that it was important for me to openly express my ideas about Israeli policies, and that it is vital for others who question to do the same.
Grossman’s comment resonated with me because Jews are a people of questioners. We emphatically question and discuss. That very Jewish form of engagement, however, is often seen as a threat rather than an asset when it comes to public discussions and criticism of Israel.
Yet, as Jews, we show that we care and are connected to each other by rigorous inquiry, not blind advocacy. Accordingly, I feel compelled to call upon Israel to redouble its efforts to bring about a two-state solution, especially as we enter spring and witness the Arab world in the midst of revolution and the possibility – however remote – of a blossoming democracy in Egypt.

Rather than being buoyed by these words—at this call for “questioners” to speak out—I find myself despairing. After all these years of occupation, with half a million Jewish settlers illegally occupying Palestinian land, with the checkpoints, the wall, and ethnic cleansing ongoing facts of life, after all the wars and threats of more wars—this is the best that Bronfman can come up with—that colonial Israel should “redouble its efforts to bring about a two-state solution.” (Math is not my strong suit, but even I know that 2 x 0 = 0, with 2 representing the “redoubling” and 0 representing the “efforts.”)

Given Bronfman’s importance in the Jewish world, his Passover homily might have been a startling, indeed a welcome, addition to the conversation a decade ago, but I am afraid that today its failure to reference any solid content renders it meaningless.

The Passover seder is based on the injunction to ask questions, and Bronfman could have laid out some serious questions for discussion. But, alas, even Edgar Bronfman is (still) afraid of telling the truth about Israel. That says it all. How sad.

New project seeks to protect Gaza fishermen’s rights and livelihood

Apr 18, 2011

Adam Horowitz

081121 eva gaza 1

An Israeli naval ship sprays a Palestinian fishing boat with a water cannon off the coast of the Gaza Strip. (Photo: David Schermerhorn)

The Civil Peace Service Gaza is beginning a new project off the coast of Gaza to protect the rights of Gazan fisherman. The “Oliva,” a human rights monitoring boat, will launch Wednesday from the port of Gaza City with an international crew from Spain, the United States, Italy and Belgium to accompany Gazan fishermen within Palestinian waters and record violations of international law.

The press release announcing the project states:

Since Operation Cast Lead, access to fishing grounds has been unilaterally restricted by Israel to three nautical miles. This dramatic reduction of the 20-mile limit, which was agreed upon in the Oslo Accords, has resulted in the overexploitation of fishing grounds in which stocks are close to exhaustion. Fishermen are threatened by gunfire, confiscation of their boats and fishing tools, and arrest by the Israeli Navy which regularly launches attacks and incursions in Palestinian waters.

The press release also mentions that Vittorio Arrigoni was part of establishing the project (they will commemorate his life and work tomorrow at the kick off event). The issue of Gaza’s fishermen was central to Arrigoni’s recent work in Gaza. Here are two previously unpublished reports he wrote detailing the deadly conditions off the coast of Gaza. Arrigoni’s close friend Daniela Loffreda shared the reports with us and requested that we change the names of those mentioned to protect their identity:

Report 1: Yousef

20 year old Yousef is the last fisherman that was killed by the Israeli navy in 2010, on the 24th of September.

Yousef was sailing on a boat with three of his cousins opposite al-Sudaniya beach, north of Gaza City. They were fishing. While they were about 2 kilometers away from the beach, an Israeli gunboat approached at a distance of 100 meters and started heavily firing the fishing boat with a machine gun. There was no reason or any warning. Yousef was shot by a bullet in the chest. His relatives carried him to Kamal Odwan Hospital in Beit Lahia where he died soon after arrival.

This is what his uncle Ali, told some ISM activists during the wake:

“It was Yousef’s first experinece at sea as a fisherman. He would have married the next month. He didn’t speak about anything else, about the wedding party and about his new life. On the day of his death, the furniture was delivered to his new home.

In addition to Yousef, two members of our family have recently become disabled: Fadi and Bilal. They can not walk anymore because of the wounds inflicted on them by Israeli bullets while they were at sea fishing.

We raise our children just like the Israelis, as they aspire to have normal and possibly happy lives, get married and have families. Due to this desire for normality we die, going to work, trying to procure at sea what we need to feed our families.

Yousef was doing nothing wrong at sea. He did not commit a crime against Israel, he was just trying to build his future. He had no weapons with him, just a net. They could stop him if they wanted, instead they wanted to kill him.

We are under siege from every side, sea and air, Gaza is not a safe place wherever you are: at home, college, street, traveling by car and fishing at sea.

This is the punishment you get when you are born Palestinian.

We thank all people everywhere that show solidarity with the Palestinian people, who speak the same language of the oppressed who resist.

A father goes off to work in the morning and then comes back dead, a child goes off to school and then must make a trip to the morgue.

I thank all the people who give us support, but it’s not enough, you have to isolate Israel in every way within the international community and boycott it.

Report 2: Ghassan

Ghassan cannot stay composed as he sits on a dock at the port of Gaza. As he gestures with one arm, the other remains limp and holds on to dear life while he tells his story to an activist from the International Solidarity Movement.
On the night of March 12, 2007 Ghassan was aboard his boat with two of his brothers. They were fishing about a mile off the coast of Rafah, preparing the lights for night fishing when they noticed an Israeli gunboat nearby that was motionless in the dark. It apparently had been watching them for some time.
Soon after, the Israeli navy boat quickly approached them at a high speed and fired directly at them, without any warning. They panicked and tried to flee to shore but the Israelis started firing missiles at them. They managed to reach the shore and hide behind their small boat when a missile fell near Ghassan, then age 26, and his 14 year old nephew. They were both seriously injured. The barrage of fire made it impossible for the Red Crescent ambulance to reach them for a long time. Precious time was lost and they were first taken to a nearby hospital in Khan Younis and then Ghassan was transferred to a hospital in Israel, but they were not able to save his arm.
“We are not terrorists, Israeli soldiers know that. They know all the fishermen of Gaza by name, have the numbers of our boats, even have our photographs. Every day we go out to sea, we never create problems for the Israelis, we are forced to challenge the illegal limit imposed by the soldiers in order to go off where the sea is rich in fish so that we can feed our families. We are not terrorists, yet we are treated as terrorists. In winter the fisherman are sometimes forced to strip naked while under Israeli fire, then jump into the sea and swim to the Israeli ships. From there the fisherman are transported to Ashdot and put in jail. Last year during one of these abductions, it happened to be Ramadan. Using the threat of death against the fisherman, the soldiers forced them to eat and drink during the fast. To me it was much worse, they tore my arm and I lost the ability to continue to work. ”
Today Ghassan spends his days hanging out at the port illuding himself to believe that he is helpful, as he patiently awaits the day when his life will be compensated. Maybe Europe will deliver a miraculous prosthesis that will once again make him the expert captain that plowed the sea of Gaza for 15 years.

International Solidarity Movement committed to staying in Gaza following Arrigoni murder

Apr 18, 2011

Adam Horowitz

The ISM just released the following statement:

Following the murder of our comrade and friend Viktor, we, activists of the International Solidarity Movement, would like to reiterate our commitment to remaining in Gaza. We will continue to work with and live among the Palestinian population as we continue the work which Vik was so committed too.

In these days of mourning, Palestinians have organized numerous memorials for Vik; they constantly remind us how sorry they are to have lost him, of how they loved him, his closeness, his affection, and his indignation at what is happening here in Gaza. We know that the group that perpetrated this horrible crime does not in any way represent the Palestinian society. The Palestinians of Gaza are our friends, our collogues, and our reason for being here; we will continue to stand by their side.

As we had done when Vittorio was with us, we will continue to stand alongside the Palestinian people, we will continue to struggle against the occupation, we will continue to accompany farmers to their lands along the border, we will continue to participate in demonstrations, and we will continue to tell the world what happens here in the Gaza Strip, Palestine. We think that Victor would agree with Che Guevara when he said, “Don’t cry for me if I die, do what I was doing and I will live on in you.” The best way to honor Vik is to continue the work that he was doing. In particular we will soon begin crewing a boat whose mission is to monitor the violation of human rights in Palestinian waters. This boat will have its maiden voyage on April 20: Vik had strongly backed this project and he had enthusiasticallyparticipated in its realization. Vik has been an inspiration to all of us, we all hope to live up to his example. In a documentary about him, Vik said he would have liked to be remembered by Nelson Mandela’s quote; “A victor is merely a dreamer who never stops dreaming.” Your dreams are our dreams; we will never forget you, Vik.

Egyptian PM to make a solidarity visit to Gaza while the Mubaraks are not adjusting well to prison life

Apr 18, 2011

Seham

And more news from the Arab uprisings:

Bahrain

Bahrain PM says protests amounted to coup attempt

MANAMA, April 18 (Reuters) – Bahrain’s Prime Minister Sheikh Khalifa bin Salman al-Khalifa said protesters, who had called for his removal, would be held to account and described the anti-government unrest as a coup attempt. “Bahrain has witnessed a coup attempt,” he said in remarks carried by pro-government media on Monday. “No violators would get away with it. All co-conspirators and abettors must be held accountable.”

http://www.trust.org/alertnet/news/bahrain-pm-says-protests-amounted-to-coup-attempt

Bahrain: Gulf troops to stay as counter to Iran (AP)

AP – Gulf troops will stay in Bahrain until its Sunni rulers are satisfied that threats from Iran have eased, the island kingdom’s foreign minister said Monday amid an ongoing crackdown on dissent.

http://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/rss/mideast/*http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110418/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_bahrain
Bahraini women die amid crackdown

At least two Bahraini women have died as a result of a crackdown on the opposition as thugs backed by Saudi forces stormed the village of Karzakan following the country-wide protests. Azizeh Hassan died in her home after pro-regime thugs stormed houses in Bilad al-Qadim district, a Press TV correspondent reported on Saturday. Moreover, a female teenager died a month after she was attacked by pro-regime thugs in Manama. Jawaher Abdul-Amir Kuwaitan was in a coma at the capital’s al-Salmaniyah Hospital.

http://presstv.com/detail/175131.html
Bahrain: Defense Lawyer Detained After Night Raid

(Manama) – More than two dozen uniformed and plainclothes security officers, most of whom were masked, raided the home of prominent defense lawyer Mohammed al-Tajer on the evening of April 15, 2011, and arrested him, Human Rights Watch said today. Neither he nor his family was given any reason for his detention.

http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2011/04/16/bahrain-defense-lawyer-detained-after-night-raid
Bahrain ‘arrests rights lawyer and doctors’
Campaigners say security forces have detained lawyer who represented leader of the Haq opposition group and two doctors.
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2011/04/20114161822138150.html
Bahrain to prosecute civil servants over protests (AP)

AP – More than a hundred civil servants in Bahrain were summarily fired for participating in anti-government protests, the state news agency said Sunday, in the latest crackdown on the opposition.

http://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/rss/mideast/*http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110417/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_bahrain
Bahrain detains former champion athlete: opposition (Reuters)

Reuters – Bahrain has detained a former bodybuilding champion as part of a crackdown on mainly Shi’ite Muslim pro-democracy protesters in the Sunni-led Gulf Arab kingdom, the opposition said on Sunday.

http://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/rss/mideast/*http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20110417/ts_nm/us_bahrain_arrest
Bahraini Activist “Angry Arabiya” Hospitalized

A Bahraini human rights activist has been hospitalized after going on a hunger strike in protest at the kingdom’s detention of her relatives. Zainab al-Khawaja, known online as “Angry Arabiya,” was taken to hospital on Sunday after seven days of hunger strike following the arrest of her father, uncle, husband and brothers-in-law.

http://presstv.com/detail/175304.html
Hospitals show ugly truth about Bahrain, as US looks the other way

TINY Bahrain, a vital American ally in the Gulf region, is reimaging itself as a classic Cold War police state in the aftermath of the democracy uprisings across the Middle East and North Africa.
http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/hospitals-show-ugly-truth-about-bahrain-as-us-looks-the-other-way-20110415-1dhw0.html
U.S. defends Bahrain policy

“Even though the American administration’s words are all about freedom and democracy and change, in Bahrain, the reality is that they’re basically a protection for the dictatorship,” said Zainab al-Khawaja, a prominent human-rights activist who went on a hunger strike after her father, husband and brother-in-law were arrested at her apartment in Bahrain during the weekend.
http://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2011/04/15/US-defends-Bahrain-policy/UPI-27661302879836/
Inside Story – Bahrain’s iron fist

Three days after Hosni Mubarak was ousted from power in Egypt, the people of Bahrain took to the streets to make their grievances heard. They were not demanding an end to the monarchy – but more representation. But a violent crackdown against protesters saw a shift in their demands. The monarchy was quick to portray the popular uprising as sectarian. Troops from Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates entered Bahrain a month later as tensions began to grow. Now in the latest move, Bahraini authorities pledged to seek court approval to dissolve two Shia opposition groups for alleged links to the protests. Why did Bahrain opt for an iron-fist approach against pro-democracy protesters? And what is the nature of the role of regional players in this Gulf country? Inside Story discusses.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8C7eOZ-kjQ8&feature=youtube_gdata
“Struggle Continues in Bahrain: Marches in Manama and Diraz” (Videos)

“With our soul and blood, we’ll redeem Bahrain!” “Down with Hamad, Down with Hamad!”
http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2011/bahrain160411.html
Bahrain’s Brutal Equation

Since razing the Pearl monument in mid-March, the Bahraini ruling regime has launched a sweeping crackdown on protesters who took to the streets to voice their anger against the Al-Khalifa family and its oppressive mores. In the last few weeks, the situation on the ground has spiralled out of control and descended to a blatant and barren form of brutality with the regime’s security and military apparatus crossing all humane boundaries. The institution of martial law has taken the meaning of a sacrosanct endorsement for one and all forms of transgressions – even women and minors haven’t been spared in this state-sponsored violence spree. Whilst the attention of global media has been fixated on the Libyan stalemate, the Al-Khalifa regime has viciously suppressed the popular protests that began on 14th February.
http://dissidentvoice.org/2011/04/bahrains-brutal-equation/
The US, Gulf Kings and Brutal Repression in Bahrain

The brutal repression of demonstrators by the US-backed monarchies continues.
http://pulsemedia.org/2011/04/17/the-us-gulf-kings-and-brutal-repression-in-bahrain/
Bahrain protests will go nowhere while the US supports its government | Ian Black

The Al-Khalifa family, who control Bahrain, has cracked down on dissent with little condemnation from the west. History and geography explain why Bahrain’s peaceful uprising was the early exception to the “Arab spring”, which began with high hopes in Tunisia and Egypt but now faces bloody uncertainties in Libya and Syria. Sitting astride the faultline between the Shia and Sunni worlds, the small Gulf island state lies at the heart of a strategically sensitive region that is dominated by bitter rivals Iran and Saudi Arabia – both very tough neighbours.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/apr/16/bahrain-protests-us-supports-government
Paul Jay, “The United States and the Gulf Arab States: Interview with Adam Hanieh”

Adam Hanieh: The GCC really is the core of capitalism in the Middle East. It’s the primary place where accumulation occurs. It’s also the linkage with the broader world market. And US foreign policy — not just the United States; Europe as well and other states — really see their relationship with the broader Middle East through the lens of the GCC. . . . As you mentioned, they have the Fifth Fleet located in Bahrain. But there’s also CENTCOM, the forward command headquarters of CENTCOM, which is essentially the military headquarters that coordinates US military policy across 27 neighboring states, including Central Asia, Afghanistan, Iraq. That CENTCOM headquarters is located in Qatar. Paul Jay: Yeah, only about five, six miles away from the Al Jazeera office, and also a major air force base.
http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2011/hanieh180411.html
Egypt

As Inmates 23 and 24, Stunned Mubaraks Adjust
They make docile inmates, their captors say, still stunned to find themselves behind bars. They eat food brought from outside, the right of any detainee who has not been convicted. But Gamal appears badly shaken and often refuses to eat. He shares a cell with Alaa. “Bear in mind they are very broken,” said a prison official who described the situation inside and spoke on the condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the media. “They do everything they are asked. They don’t raise their voices.”

Egypt ministers face corruption charges
Public prosecutor targets country’s former premier and former finance and interior ministers.
http://english.aljazeera.net//news/middleeast/2011/04/201141715562214192.html
Egypt antiquities chief faces jail time
Court strips Zahi Hawass of his ministerial post after he allegedly ignored earlier land dispute ruling.
http://english.aljazeera.net//news/middleeast/2011/04/201141720122512511.html
Egyptian Court Formally Breaks Up Mubarak’s Party
The dissolution of the National Democratic Party continued the process of dismantling Hosni Mubarak’s institutions of power.
http://feeds.nytimes.com/click.phdo?i=cd9af6dea3aad90cbb48834afccbeff0
Egyptian newspapers and Mubarak family
It is a lot of fun to read Egyptian newspapers and their extensive and detailed coverage of the lives of Mubarak family members in jail.  It seems, that Mubarak asked prosecutors to punish him, but to spare his sons.  The two sons have grown beards, and Suzanne Mubarak has lost a lot of weight and wore the same dress for three days straight.  This is my summary.
http://angryarab.blogspot.com/2011/04/egyptian-newspapers-and-mubarak-family.html
Egyptian Foreign Minister to visit Gaza “in solidarity”
The Palestinian Quds Press has reported that Egypt’s new Foreign Minister, Nabil El-Arabi, is to visit the Gaza Strip. Preparations are being made for his visit, claims Egyptian journalist Ibrahim El-Darrawy, the head of the Cairo-based Palestinian Studies Centre. According to Al-Darrawy, Mr El-Arabi’s visit to besieged Gaza has been scheduled for some time; the intention is to support Palestinian reconciliation efforts and express solidarity with Gaza following recent Israeli attacks. “The plans for a Gaza visit haven’t been denied by the Minister’s office,” said Al-Darrawy, “although they are still at an early stage.” They have, he added, been on the agenda for some time and are in part designed to prevent any further Israeli aggression.
http://www.middleeastmonitor.org.uk/news/middle-east/2253-egyptian-foreign-minister-to-visit-gaza-qin-solidarityq
Libya

Libya: Indiscriminate Attacks Kill Civilians
(Misrata) – Libyan government forces have launched indiscriminate rocket and mortar attacks on residential neighborhoods in the rebel-held city of Misrata, Human Rights Watch said today. One strike, apparently by a Grad rocket, killed at least eight civilians waiting in line for bread. Another attack, apparently with a mortar round, hit a medical clinic, wounding four others.
http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2011/04/17/libya-indiscriminate-attacks-kill-civilians
Misrata Death Toll Hits 17: Fierce Fighting In Last Major Rebel Foothold In Western Libya
AJDABIYA, Libya — Holding out under a rain of shelling and sniper fire, Libyan rebels fought Moammar Gadhafi’s forces Sunday in close-quarters battles in the city center of Misrata, the last major rebel foothold in western Libya. Seventeen people were killed, an NGO worker and an opposition activist said.  Government troops have been laying siege to the city on Libya’s Mediterranean coast for weeks, prompting repeated international warnings of a dire humanitarian situation as well as calls for NATO forces to intensify airstrikes on Gadhafi’s forces there.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/17/misrata-death-toll-hits-1_n_850300.html
Several dead; Libyans demand help against Gaddafi troops
At least four people were killed and 30 injured as violence erupted in the eastern city of Brega, Al Arabiya broadcaster reported, citing witnesses.
http://www.monstersandcritics.com/news/africa/news/article_1633420.php/Several-dead-Libyans-demand-help-against-Gaddafi-troops
Libyan rebels, NATO in joint military operations against Qaddafi forces
Libya’s rebels and NATO forces have established a joint operations room, said the spokesman of the National Transitional Council, Abdul Hafiz Ghoga. This was reported Saturday evening by Agence-France Presse.
http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2011/04/16/145587.html
Fighting intensifies across Libya
Fighting escalates in the Libyan port of Misrata and elsewhere as government forces attempt to retake the rebel-held city after a two-month siege.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/int/news/-/news/world-africa-13107131
Rebel-held Libyan city pounded
Pro-Gaddafi forces rain rockets on Misurata amid reports of rebels reinforcing positions beyond Ajdabiya in the east.
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/africa/2011/04/20114168572393746.html
Gaddafi troops outflank rebels
As fighting continues for Brega, home to several oil facilities, forces loyal to long time leader Muammar Gaddafi skirt that body of fighting and attack Ajdabiya from the south. A large sandstorm has prevented NATO aircraft from targeting the troops, alowing them to set up artillery positions without fear of air strikes. Al Jazeera’s Mike Hanna, reporting from just outside Ajdabiya, and Sue Turton in Benghazi, give the latest details on the fighting along Libya’s coast.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mllxd-Hiu7o&feature=youtube_gdata
Battle for Libya: Rebel forces advance to west
Anti-aircraft fire and explosions have been heard in the Libyan capital Tripoli. It is not clear who is being targeted in the attacks. Meanwhile NATO has continued its air assault on Muammar Gaddaffi’s forces in the eastern town of Brega. Rebel forces are reportedly advancing on the oil town, as they push on from nearby Ajdabiya. Al Jazeera Sue Turton filed this report from Brega.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQHiM4F3Ih4&feature=youtube_gdata
Rebels Flee Key Libyan Town
Opposition fighters fled from Ajdabiya on Sunday after a rocket and artillery attack by forces loyal to Col. Muammar el-Qaddafi.
http://feeds.nytimes.com/click.phdo?i=a9bbcfaff5f13f1cd5e457354eb5fcd6
Libyan rebels resist Ajdabiya assault
Anti-government forces hold sway in key town but frontline fighters complain of lack of supplies and fear infiltrators.
http://english.aljazeera.net//news/africa/2011/04/2011417192411769432.html
Libyan Rebels Say They’re Being Sent Weapons
Gen. Abdel Fattah Younes, the rebel military leader, said his forces had received arms shipments from unnamed nations that support their uprising.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/17/world/africa/17libya.html
Report: US seeking country to take in Gaddafi
Obama administration said to be searching for nation willing to offer embattled Libyan ruler refuge
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4057709,00.html
Libya letter by Obama, Cameron and Sarkozy: Full text
President Barack Obama of the US, Prime Minister David Cameron of the UK and President Nicolas Sarkozy of France have written a joint letter to The Times of London, the International Herald Tribune and Le Figaro, vowing to keep up the pressure on Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi and pledging to maintain Nato military pressure on his forces.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-13090646
Libya: Berlusconi says Italy won’t bomb Gaddafi’s forces
Italy will not drop bombs on Libya, its former colony, prime minister Silvio Berlusconi said on Friday. We’ve already done enough,” he said during a cabinet meeting, according to Italian news reports.
http://www.adnkronos.com/IGN/Aki/English/Politics/Libya-Berlusconi-says-Italy-wont-bomb-Gaddafis-forces_311907473016.html
LIBYA: Traumatized evacuees describe Misrata horror
BENGHAZI 18 April 2011 (IRIN) – Civilians evacuated from the war-ravaged western Libyan city of Misrata have described the humanitarian situation there as grim, saying families are barely able to find enough food and water, that medical treatment is hard to come by, and corpses are lying in the streets.
http://www.irinnews.org/report.aspx?ReportId=92501
Libyan civilian casualties rise in Misurata
Doctors work on patients in tents and grieve for a girl killed by a sniper in a city whose misery has become symbolic of the war in Libya. The doctors rushed through a white outdoor tent where several pale, bloodied men were being operated on. Inside the Hikma hospital, it was a similar scene.
http://feeds.latimes.com/%7Er/latimes/middleeast/%7E3/7cnpJEkPGr8/la-fg-libya-boat-20110418,0,6100588.story
Libya humanitarian crisis ‘dire’
The UK says it is to hold talks at the United Nations about the “dire” humanitarian crisis affecting residents in western Libya.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/int/news/-/news/uk-13110696
Libya’s growing humanitarian crisis
The western Libyan city of Misurata continues to be under siege by Muammar Gaddafi’s forces. Its only lifelines are the sea routes to Benghazi, Tunis, and Malta, from where a steady stream of supplies has been trickling in over the past few weeks. However, supplies such as food and medicine are running short in Misurata, Libya’s third largest city. Al Jazeera’s Jonah Hull and cameraman Craig Pennington, boarded a trawler carrying humanitarian supplies, for a 24-hour voyage to the city. Warning: This exclusive package contains images that may disturb or offend some viewers.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZB-N1PLi_Q&feature=youtube_gdata
Ajdabiyah hospital staff stays put as civilians flee
AJDABIYAH, Libya, April 17 (Reuters) – Through rocket strikes and street battles, volunteer medics have been keeping Ajdabiyah’s main hospital open even as most of the embattled eastern Libyan city has packed up and left. Ajdabiyah is the gateway to the rebel stronghold of Benghazi, and thus its hospital is the first stop for many of the wounded brought back from the frontlines of fighting between insurgents and forces loyal to Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi.
http://www.trust.org/alertnet/news/ajdabiyah-hospital-staff-stays-put-as-civilians-flee
In Libya chaos, relatives of missing can only pray
BENGHAZI, Libya, April 17 (Reuters) – Ex-policeman Mohammad Ali Jarbou was so relieved NATO jets destroyed Libyan government tanks outside the rebel capital Benghazi last month that he and two friends rushed next day to take pictures. None of them have been seen since.
http://www.trust.org/alertnet/news/in-libya-chaos-relatives-of-missing-can-only-pray
Libyan Revolution : Supernatural allies
First of all here is the good news of the day : Egyptian medic volunteer Abdel Khalek has been released and he is in his way to home insh Allah. Thank Goodness for his safety. Not less than 2000 Egyptians have returned back home to the country in the past 48 hours. Here is an important report in English from Misurata refugee camp , please spread it everywhere. It was shot by Dr. Hamza ,this real citizen journalism coverage outside the country in zone like Libya.
http://egyptianchronicles.blogspot.com/2011/04/libyan-revolution-supernatural-allies.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+EgyptianChronicles+%28Egyptian+chronicles%29
Update: Battle for Libya
Anti-aircraft fire has been seen in the sky over the Libyan capital, Tripoli. Earlier, Pro-Gaddafi forces launched another barrage of rockets and mortars against Misurata. Libya’s government has denied accusations it used cluster bombs in Misurata. On Friday, the advocacy group Human Rights Watch said it had observed cluster munitions explode over the city. The weapons are banned by more than one hundred countries. Earlier, a resident of Misurata explained what he saw to Al Jazeera.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUUWMv5q2VE&feature=youtube_gdata
Mike Hanna in Benghazi
As the siege by forces loyal to longterm Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi on Misurata tightens, tanks enter the city and push civilians closer to the port area. With evidence emerging of the use of cluster bombs by Gaddafi’s forces, fears are growing for the city’s population. Al Jazeera’s Mike Hanna, reporting from Benghazi, gives us the latest on events in Libya.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JuwsGduIq8M&feature=youtube_gdata
Frost Over the World – Fleeing Misurata
Actress Olivia Williams and ‘Lost’ star Matthew Fox talk about their West End play, ‘In A Forest Dark and Deep’. Plus, environmentalist George Monbiot explains why he supports nuclear power, despite the recent disaster in Fukushima, Japan. Finally, Ambassador William L Swing, the director-general of the International Organization for Migration, talks about the ongoing refugee crisis in the Libyan city of Misurata.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sw52kcHHEi4&feature=youtube_gdata
This is / was Misurata
Above, a recent picture of the Libyan town of Misurata by the Telegraph‘s Geoff Pough. Below, a video of the town shot during Ramadan 2010, by YouTube user HoneyBees1885. Brings it home. More about the destruction of Misurata at theNYT. And the song is great — the YouTube comments say it’s by Reda Aqraf (رضا أقراف). Via Andy Carvin and LibyaInMe on Twitter.
http://www.arabist.net/blog/2011/4/16/this-is-was-misurata.html
Frost Over the World – The way ahead in Libya
During an informal NATO meeting in Berlin, Sir David Frost talks to Carl Bildt, the Swedish foreign minister, about the way ahead in Libya. Plus, Charlie Parker the editor of Citywire on spiralling oil prices and Ad Melkert, the UN special representative for Iraq, gives a progress report on the country eight months before American troops withdraw.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YsAVaGwS-uU&feature=youtube_gdata
Massoud Abu Assir, Libyan Rebel Guitarist Plays On Outskirts Of Ajdabiya
AJDABIYA, Libya — The Libyan revolution has been tough on rebel fighter and guitarist Massoud Abu Assir’s rock band. His bass player was captured by Moammar Gadhafi’s forces, and his drummer is off fighting on the front line. But those setbacks haven’t stopped the 38-year-old amateur musician from composing songs in support of the revolution and performing them for rebels on the battlefield. He made an appearance Saturday on the outskirts of the front line city of Ajdabiya as fierce fighting raged about 25 miles (40 kilometers) away.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/16/massoud-abu-assir-libyan-rebel-guitarist-_n_850100.html
Syria

U.S. Secretly Backed Syrian Opposition Groups, Cables Released By WikiLeaks Show
The State Department has secretly financed Syrian political opposition groups and related projects, including a satellite TV channel that beams anti-government programming into the country, according to previously undisclosed diplomatic cables.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/17/us-syria-opposition_n_850302.html
WikiLeaks: US Embassy Cables: : Hariri proposed new Syria regime
Leaked diplomatic cables allege that Saad Al-Hariri suggested isolating Bashar Al-Assad and forming a coalition of Muslim Brotherhood and former regime figures to take power.
http://english.ahram.org.eg/%7E/NewsContent/2/8/10122/World/Region/WikiLeaks-Hariri-proposed-new-Syria-regime.aspx
Thousands attend Syria protesters’ funerals
Mourners call for overthrow of President Assad a day after at least 30 demonstrators were killed by security forces.
http://english.aljazeera.net//news/middleeast/2011/04/201141813455655509.html
Syria protesters killed in Homs
At least 17 pro-democracy demonstrators were killed by security forces as demands for president Assad’s ouster continue.
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2011/04/201141810355592109.html
Syria’s Assad swears in new government
President chairs cabinet’s first session as state media says one policeman was killed in Friday’s clashes.
http://english.aljazeera.net//news/middleeast/2011/04/201141683355504200.html
Assad to abolish emergency law
President Bashar al-Assad of Syrian promised his countrymen on Saturday that he would lift the draconian emergency law within a week, after month-long protests rocked Syria and left at least 200 people dead.
http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2011/04/16/145654.html
Policeman dies amid Syrian protest
A Syrian policeman is reported to have died after being beaten by protesters during a demonstration in a central city.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/policeman-dies-amid-syrian-protest-2268801.html
Syrians protest despite Assad concessions
Hundreds rally in the southern city of Suweida, a day after the president vowed to lift emergency law within a week.
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2011/04/2011417131422534165.html
Tunisia

Wife of ousted Tunisian president “a Mossad agent”
The bodyguard of the ousted Tunisian President Zen El Abedeen Ben Ali has said that Ben Ali and his wife Laila El Trabolsi are supporters of Israel. Abdel Rahman Sobeir also claims that El Trabolsi is a Mossad agent who was involved in several assassinations of Palestinian leaders when they were exiled in Tunisia. Mr Sobeir revealed this sensitive information on Facebook; he accused Tunisia’s ex-First Couple and their son-in-law Selim Shaiboub, along with a number of senior security chiefs, of criminal activity. According to reports in the Algerian newspaper Al Shorouk, in 1991 Laila Ben Ali recruited two agents in the Tunisian intelligence services to assassinate a Tunisian businessman who was a close friend of Ben Ali but had opposed her marriage to the ousted president. “Ben Ali’s son-in-law was behind the death of a four-year-old girl in the Radeif area in 1992, an act proved by state security investigators,” claims Sobeir. He added that there are many more treasures in the Carthage Palace than have been disclosed. The treasures include gold and sapphire decorations brought together by Leila and her brother Belhasan.
http://www.middleeastmonitor.org.uk/news/middle-east/2254-wife-of-ousted-tunisian-president-qa-mossad-agentq
“Tunisians Protest at Saudi Embassy: Extradite Fugitive Ben Ali!” (Videos)
Several thousands of Tunisians protested outside the Saudi Embassy on 15 April 2011, demanding the extradition of fugitive Zine El Abidine Ben Ali.
http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2011/tunisia170411.html
In Tunisia, where record keeping is good, some seek to preserve documents of tyranny
In Tunisia, undergoing a transformation from dictatorship to possible democracy, some make an effort to collect and preserve regime archives, very few of which have been made public. The unassuming whitewashed building is crammed full of explosive material potentially more damaging, or vital, to Tunisia’s democratic experiment than any incendiary device.
http://feeds.latimes.com/%7Er/latimes/middleeast/%7E3/tLnCTEghNlY/la-fg-tunisia-archives-20110417,0,1415313.story
Yemen

Yemeni troops ‘open fire on protesters’
Reports of more clashes come as leaders of opposition bloc head to Saudi Arabia to discuss transition of power.
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2011/04/201141715495475107.html
Yemeni women protest over Saleh criticism
Thousands reject president’s view that it is un-Islamic for women to join men in demonstrations against his rule.
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2011/04/2011416162256587141.html

Yemen opposition to join Gulf-brokered talks
Leaders of opposition bloc head to Saudi Arabia to discuss transition of power with Gulf ministers amid protests
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/middleeast/2011/04/20114174454614208.html
Other

United Arab Emirates: The Making of a Police State
Over the last few years, the UAE has become increasingly oppressive. The recent crackdowns show how bad it really is.
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/04/14/the_making_of_a_police_state
Arab Dictators’ Children: The Mixed Fortunes Of Gaddafi And Mubarak’s Kids
Muammar Gaddafi’s only daughter, Aisha, found herself the subject of many international headlines this week after sherallied a crowd early Friday from a balcony at her father’s compound. For 35-year-old Aisha, who’s been branded North Africa’s “Claudia Schiffer” due to her glamorous image, it was the most overtly political gesture to date. (Previously, she has grabbed headlines over an alleged affair with Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi). She’s not the only known member of the Gaddafi family carrying her father’s legacy. As Time reports, brother Saif, 40, is known as a shrewd operator and canny businessman, while 39-year-old Saadi enjoyed a brief Italian soccer career. Little is known about Khamis, said to have died in a kamikaze attack, or Milad, a nephew whom Gaddafi adopted.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/04/16/arab-dictators-children-t_n_849969.html


Kidnapped in Gaza

Apr 18, 2011

Vittorio Arrigoni

The following was sent to us by Daniela Loffreda, a close friend of Vittorio Arrigoni.  She writes: “This is a chilling account from Vittorio’s blog of what happened to him and other ISM activists when they were kidnapped by the Israeli military in 2008. The media keeps focusing on how Hamas doesn’t have control of Gaza and security. And I ask myself, had Vittorio tried to leave via Israel what would of happened to him, again? He was jailed and captured (and tortured) by IDF twice.”

vik
Vittorio Arrigoni (Photo courtesy of Daniela Loffreda)

Last Tuesday the sea was a placid, liquid blanket, unruffled and as smooth as oil when Darlene, Andrew and I, human rights activists with the ISM sailed from the port of Gaza on three Palestinian fishing boats. The warm sun, clear blue sky and complete absence of wind had led us to expect a plentiful day’s catch for our fishermen friends. Around 11 AM we were intercepted and circled by eight Israeli military boats opening fire against the fishing boats, obstructing our way, after which they proceeded to kidnap us three internationals and fifteen Palestinian fishermen. They abducted us and stole the boats, leading us and the boats from the Palestinian water zone right to the border with Israel’s. We were about six miles from the coast of Gaza, which according to international laws is unequivocally in Palestinian waters (the Oslo Treaty gives the Palestinians sovereignty up to 20 miles from the coast of the Strip), meaning ours wasn’t an arrest but a full-blown abduction, with the fishing boats being stolen rather than confiscated. A veritable terrorist blitz. Israeli Navy special forces, commandos, balaklava-wearing, unfathomably armed, all to stop just three small wooden boats that could barely stay afloat.

I tried to speak to the Israeli Officer who seemed the highest in ranking, asking him whether they were planning to kill me. I could see more than ten pistols, guns and cannon barrels pointing at me, following my every move. Before the Israeli soldiers jumped on board the fishing boat, I asking him and them what kind of obsessive fear Israel nurtured, what degree of extreme danger for its domestic security could be represented by a bunch of simple Palestinian fishermen going offshore, within their own sea zone, to catch just enough fish to feed their families with.

The Israeli Officer, so iron-willed and authoritarian when barking orders in Hebrew at his soldiers and in English (with a distinctly Australian accent) at me, had nothing to say in reply to my simple query. These soldiers, all muscles and stony coldness, are trained to kill a man in less than a second (or less when he’s Palestinian), without even batting an eyelid. But it’s obvious they’re unable to willingly grasp the meaning of simple terms such as “right to exist” and “right of sustenance”.

Since we were far from Israeli borders, I told the Israeli Officer I didn’t recognize his authority, nor their right to kidnap myself and my friends, the fishermen. I therefore decided I would resist passively, non-violently. I climbed onto the cabin roof, and from there onto the iron structure used as a jib to lift the fishing nets, at the boat’s stern. Three soldiers followed me, pointing guns in my face. Their eyes behind the black balaklavas seemed to me like the best representation of hatred that I had ever seen, a hatred taught in years of lessons learnt off by heart, on how to best defeat an enemy, even when that enemy doesn’t exist. Not in the least bit intimidated, I asked them whether they intended to kill me, and if so to go ahead and finish off their job then and there.

Go ahead and kill a civilian, a disarmed Italian on a Palestinian fishing boat, gone fishing with his Palestinian friends on Palestinian waters. A fourth soldier came forward, and I recognized the weapon he was holding, a taser gun. I told him the truth, that I have a heart condition. His weapon could have given me a cardiac arrest. The soldier got closer, the Officer gave him the order and I turned my back on both of them, so as not too feel too much compassion for them. The soldier shot me in the back, an electric shock that knocked me right out, then all four soldiers tried to push me down the three-meter leap, down onto the stern’s steel floor that could have provoked serious fractures in me. I lunged forward and leapt into the sea, swimming slowly with what strength I had left. I swam towards the shore on the horizon, towards Gaza, towards my home. Indifferent to the intimidating bullets hitting the water a few centimeters from my head, I swam for a good half hour, followed at a short distance by the eight war ships. But when my teeth started to chatter uncontrollably and the palms of my hands turned blue, I had to give in and let the soldiers pull me out of the water, beating me up as they did so. I narrowly missed hypothermia.

When we got to the port of Ashkelon, myself, Darlene and Andrew were marched out of the Israeli war ship and were met by a scenario reminiscent of the Holocaust. It was something that reminded me of Schindler’s List, or the horror-imbued prose of Primo Levi. All the fishermen were made to kneel, stark naked, chained at the ankles and handcuffed with their arms behind their backs, blindfolded. These were the conditions they had been made to travel in, on an open deck for 50 nautical kilometers.

Why so? For what reason on earth does Israel, through its army and government, soil its reputation with such crimes against the civilians of Gaza on a daily basis? Why does it impose these collective punishments? Preventing harmless fishermen from catching fish a few miles from the coast, in their own water zone, and more generally starving Gaza’s population held captive in its siege, certainly doesn’t favor the peace process, nor will it give Israel more security. The exact opposite is true.

Us three internationals were lead into a prison at Ben Gurion, followed by another one in Ramle, where we immediately went on a hunger strike to ask for the immediate release of the Palestinian fishermen, which eventually took place.

I was held for six days in that Israeli jail in terrible conditions, in filthy and claustrophobic cells, crawling with insects and parasites that feasted on my skin. But coming from Gaza, I was used to being held under chain. Through Israel’s will, Gaza is the biggest open-air prison in the world. All the industries have had to close down, over 80% of the population survives under the poverty line and the highest rates of unemployment in the world are recorded in Gaza. There’s no electricity or fuel. Hospitals need medicine, the vast majority of the population need food and the bare essentials. The Israelis only conducted me from one open-air prison to another of their own smaller ones, where at least, unlike in Gaza, they regularly serve rations and both electricity and drinking water are available almost daily.

But I was denied the most basic of human rights, such as the faculty to contact my attorney or consulate at my own discretion rather than my jailers’. Furthermore, I am keen to speak out against the prison of Ramle, twenty kilometers from Tel Aviv, where hundreds of African refugees, mostly Ethiopian, Eritrean and Sudanese, are virtually buried alive. They have perfectly valid UN visa passes; in any self-styled civilized country they would have been assigned accommodation and the bare essentials to survive. They’re fleeing from war – they’re no terrorists. But once again, when it comes to human rights, and more generally to international law, Israel have demonstrated that it’s just a bunch of hollow words to them outside their borders, as well as within them. I’ll do everything in my power to let the inhuman conditions of my inmates be known – I promised them I would.

In the end, Andrew, Darlene and I were deported. We didn’t appeal to an Israeli court so as not to legitimize our arrest, which is considered a kidnapping under international law.

Our lawyers will battle it out to have the fishing boats returned. Besides the financial loss suffered by the boats’ owners, what’s really aggravating us is the thought of fifty unemployed fishermen, and about thirty Palestinian families without a means of sustenance for the last week.

Those boats robbed by Israel are a symbol of the siege under which Gaza is forcibly held, the illegality bordering on terrorism with which the Israeli Army operates outside its territory. Personally, I, Vittorio Arrigoni, declare that I’m a lion. The more I get flogged, the more they jail me, the steelier my will to fight for human rights becomes. It was no laughing matter for Gandhi and his companions to shake off the British occupation, nor for Mandela to defeat the Apartheid that reigned supreme in South Africa. Neither the wounds inflicted upon me in these months in Gaza, nor has my last confinement sufficed to make me take a single step back on the path towards the non-violent civic struggle I undertook. It’s a moral matter that spells freedom for the Palestinians, and simultaneously peace and security for the Israelis.

Stay human,

Vittorio Arrigoni

El-Haddad: Goldstone’s opinion might have changed, but the facts in Gaza have not

Apr 18, 2011

Adam Horowitz

Gazamom blogger, and Goldstone Report contributor, Laila El-Haddad responds to the Goldstone’s reconsideration with a Baltimore Sun Op-Ed “Palestinians betrayed by Judge Goldstone“:

The Goldstone Report meant to accomplish accountability, reporting not only on the destruction and massacres committed during the Gaza attack but calling for an examination of the intent of senior leaders and for action against perpetrators of war crimes.

But Judge Goldstone’s op-ed is an affront to the rights of victims, both Palestinian and Israeli, and our desire — our right — to truth and justice.

Palestinians feel abandoned by Judge Goldstone. Here is a leading advocate for human rights giving every impression of deserting a civilian and refugee population — particularly the Samouni family, which lost 29 members over several terrifying days, but also Palestinians like Dr. Ezzeldeen Abu al-Aish, who was present when three daughters and a niece were killed by Israeli shelling.

Meanwhile, the Israeli army continues to operate with complete impunity, killing 19 Palestinians in Gaza earlier this month. On Jan. 10, they shot dead a 65-year-old farmer tending to his land along Gaza’s border — a repeat of an incident I reported in September, when Israeli forces killed a 92-year-old shepherd, his 14-year-old grandson and his 17-year-old friend with a series of artillery shells, even though they were clearly visible (by the army’s own admission days later).

It merits reminding that the Goldstone Report had many other damning conclusions, including finding that the ongoing blockade of Gaza constitutes a violation of Israel’s obligations as an occupying power. The blockade deprives Palestinians of their most basic freedoms: freedom to build, to move in and out of one’s home to the rest of the occupied Palestinian Territories or to the world, to fish more than three miles out to sea, to marry who you want and live where you want, to study, to read, to farm, to build, to live, to prosper. It dysfunctionalizes life and cripples livelihoods.

There has been plenty written in the past two weeks about Judge Goldstone. Some say he buckled under pressure after being ostracized from the Jewish community. Some say he had a change of mind and others that he actually did not retract much.

One thing is certain: Though Judge Goldstone’s opinion may have changed on the deliberateness of Israel’s killings, the facts on the ground and the eyewitness testimonies one hears on every corner of the Gaza Strip have not. They are the greatest evidence.

The need to hold Israel accountable for its crimes and to implement the recommendations of the Goldstone Report have never been more salient. To quote Judge Goldstone himself, “the debate should continue, not attempt to be silenced.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *