Carlotta Gall & US Twofold Diplomacy towards Pakistan


By Sajjad Shaukat
Despite the fact that a number of strategic institutes and thinktanks play a key role in formulation
of American external policies, but contradictory statements of the US president, high officials
and media have always reflected that the United States has been acting upon a twofold
diplomacy twards Pakistan.
In the last few years, while ignoring the responsibilities of the US, ISAF and Karzai-led troops
in Afghanistan, especially US civil and military high officials have unilaterally been blaming
Pakistan to ‘do more’ against the militancy in the tribal regions in order to stop cross-border
terrorism in Afghanistan.
In this regard, the then US Defence Secretary Robert Gates, while repeating the false allegations
had accused Pak Army and Pakistan’s intelligence agency, ISI of close contact with the Haqqani
network and militant’s infilteration in Afghanistan. US Chairmen of the Joint Chiefs of Staff,
Admiral Mike Mullen had also alleged that ISI has been supporting, funding, training fighters
that are killing Americans and killing coalition partners in Afghanistan.
During her visit to India, the then US Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, while showing US
paradoxical approach had remarked, “New Delhi would bring prosperity and peace to India,
Pakistan and Afghanistan…Pakistan must do more to tackle terror groups operating from its
territory being used for attacks that destabilise Afghanistan or India.” And when she visited
Pakisan, she said that Pakistan should take “strong steps to dismantle safe havens of Afghan
insurgents and encourage Taliban to enter negotiations in good faith.” But she clarified that the
US was not asking Pakistan to sacrifice its own security, saying, “Pakistan has a critical role to
play in supporting Afghan reconciliation and ending the conflict.” Replying to a question that ISI
was involved in attack on the US embassy in Kabul through Haqqani network, she categorically
pointed out, “We have no evidence of that.”
The US Secretary of State explained, “Her country is also committed to the economic
development of Pakistan”, and “supports regional economic integration between Pakistan and all
However, if we take note of the US strategy about Pakistan, we observe that American policy
goals are quite unclear. Sometimes, US top officials admire Pak Army’s action against the
Taliban militants including arrests of the top Al Qaeda commanders by the ISI, sometimes, they
revive their blame game against ISI including its links with the Haqqani network, sometimes
they accuse that Al Qaeda Shura has been operating from Pakistan, sometimes, they misconceive
that Pak nukes are not safe, sometimes, they show their determination to maintain ties with
Pakistan and sometimes they threaten to stop aid of Islamabad, while sometimes to carry on the
The fact of the matter is that US has been acting upon a twofold diplomacy towards Pakistan. In
this context, American CIA with the help of Indian RAW and Israeli Mossad has continuously
been weakening Pakistan through subversive acts which keep on going in the country because
it is the only nuclear state in the Islamic World. Washington which signed an agreement of civil
nuclear technology with New Delhi in 2008 wants to counterbalance China by India. US-led
some western countries also have tilt towards India as they consider it their larger market at the
Nevertheless, Pakistan which had been granted the status of Non-NATO ally by America has
now become a target of maliscious propaganda. Besides the collective connivance of their secret
agences, the media of the US, India and some western countries leave no stone unturned in
distorting the image of Pakistan, its army and ISI by continuing old allegations in wake of new
In this connection, a female journalist, Carlotta Gall has always showed venomous drive
against Pakistan. She has allegedly stated, “The Red Mosque stood at the centre of Pakistan’s
support for Jihad in Afghanistan and throughout Muslim world. That Pakistan’s strategy is
to show cooperation with the America’s fight against terrorism while covertly abetting and
even coordinating Taliban and Al-Qaeda militants. 95% of Taliban fighting in Afghanistan
are educated and trained in Haqqania Madrassa in Akora Khattak”. But, it is the past story
when Soviets were the occupiers in Afghanistan, and Jihadi factions were used as a fodder to
implement US amd Western plan.
In her book, titled “The Wrong Enemy: America in Afghanistan 2001-2004”, Carlotta Gall
wrote: “The terror attack on the Indian Embassy in Kabul in 2008 that left 58 people dead, was
sanctioned and monitored by senior officials of Pakistan’s ISI”. This is a deliberate lie, because
there is no evidence to substantiate this allegation. In late 1970s and early 1980s, when Soviet
forces were forced to withdraw from Afghanistan with active cooperation of Pakistan, the then
government believed that Pakistan would have strategic depth in Afghanistan. In 1950s and
1960s, the then Pakistan governments had found strategic depth in Iran, as Tehran was member
of CENTO. But that was a flawed policy. Now, Pakistan as a nation has confidence in itself and
its armed forces, and does not look for strategic depth in other countries.
Partucularly, there is a paradigm shift in Pakistan’s policy, and Islamabad has a hands off policy
regarding Afghanistan, despite negative propaganda by western intelligentsia including Carlotta
Gall who stated, “Organizers of insurgencies in Afghanistan are in Pakistan and that these are
well protected by ISI”. Anyhow, Pakistan neither harbor ambitions, nor has the intention to
interfere in Afghanistan’s internal affairs. Pakistan government has taken confidence building
measures and has given gestures to show its sincerity that it desires to see Afghanistan as a stable
and peaceful country.
It was owing to this realization that none of the Afghan President candidates resorted to
Pakistan-bashing during their recent election campaign. Pakistan’s cooperation in Global
War on Terror has been an outstanding feature of NATO’s Afghan campaign. But Carlotta
Gall is trying to defame Pakistan on the lines of India by accusing that Islamabad is playing a
double game. Such allegations are baseless and wicked in nature. Carlotta Gall’s accusations
about Red Mosque and assassination of Benazir Bhutto are reflections of a sick mind. She is
a senior journalist who at the present, covers Pakistan and Afghanistan for New York Times.
Unfortunately, Carlotta Gall showed utter disregard to the journalistic norms, and also did not
bother about her self-respect and dignity. Her allegations about Gen. Musharraf, Shuja Pasha and
Ziauddin Butt are totally unfounded; and so is the case of her false reporting about Hafiz Saeed
and Mulla Omer. Her malicious propaganda against Pakistan, Pak Army and ISI is an effort to
denigrate these institutions and create a market for selling her book. As a journalist, she should
not stoop so low as to defame a state and its national institutions to make money or to achieve
personal prominence.
Undoubtedly, she works with anti-Pakistan elements like Fareed Zakria, an Indian national
who always showed a deep-seated animosity against Pakistan and leaves no stone unturned in
showing Pakistan in bad light. New York Times often published stories denigrating Pakistan
and its key institutions, and the excerpts of Carlotta Gall’s book were also published in the
form of an article by this daily. In the past, apart from America’s duplicity, American media
is also responsible for deteriorating relations between Pakistan and the United States. The
downward slide in relations had begun when a CIA contractor Raymond Davis shot and killed
two Pakistanis in Lahore. This was followed by the cladestne American raid which killed
Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad—an operation that was seen as a open violation of Pakistan’s
sovereignty. Ties hit their lowest level after the US attack on two Afghan border posts on 26,
2011 which killed 24 Pakistani soldiers. While, the US realized its mistakes by expressing regret
over the incident, and tendered apology in that respect. When efforts are being made to remove
the misunderstandings, American media and writers should not throw spanner in the works.
As regards the issue of cross-border terrorism, it is notable that since April, 2011, about 200 to
500 heavily-armed insurgents from Afghanistan’s side entered Pakistan’s region from time to
time. They targeted the security check posts and other infrastructure of the tribal areas, and killed
several innocent persons and personnel of the security forces. In his meeting with the NATO/
ISAF Commander in Afghanistan, Gen. Joseph F Dunford on April 1, 2013, Gen. Kayani asked
him to stop cross-border infiltration from Afghanistan.
Nonetheless, the book of Carlotta Gall is a part of nefarious and venomous anti-Pakistan
propaganda which reflects the US twofold diplomacy towards Pakistan.
Sajjad Shaukat writes on international affairs and is author of the book: US vs Islamic Militants,
Invisible Balance of Power: Dangerous Shift in International Relations

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.